新能源汽车需求市场培育的政策取向:供给侧抑或需求侧Study of the New Energy Vehicles Demand Market' s Cultivated Policy Orientation:Supply Side or Demand Side
熊勇清,陈曼琳
摘要(Abstract):
政策支持是促进新能源汽车消费市场等商业化条件成熟的重要手段。近年来,中央和一些地方政府在新能源汽车需求市场培育的"供给侧"和"需求侧"都先后出台了相应的市场培育政策。"供给侧"和"需求侧"的政策功能与效果不完全相同,地方政府在选择和应用新能源汽车需求培育政策时面临着诸多困惑。论文尝试将基尼系数分解法引入到新能源汽车需求市场"供给侧"和"需求侧"政策实施效果的区域差异分析中,分析了我国培育新能源汽车消费市场培养"供给侧"和"需求侧"政策取向的分布情况以及现阶段政策取向所面临的困惑,应用我国新能源汽车试点推广城市数据开展了实证研究。结果表明,"供给侧"政策着力于改善新能源汽车消费市场供给体系的质量和效率,为需求市场持续发展提供驱动力量;"需求侧"政策着力于激发新能源汽车消费的积极性和购买能力,为需求市场持续发展提供拉动力量。"供给侧"和"需求侧"政策在不同收入水平区域试点城市中的实施效果存在差异,高收入区域试点城市"供给侧"和"需求侧"政策都有着明显效果,但是"供给侧"政策效果更为显著;中等收入区域试点城市"需求侧"政策效果十分显著,"供给侧"政策效果相对较弱;收入稍低区域试点城市则以"供给侧"政策效果更为显著,"需求侧"政策效果相对较弱。我国新能源汽车市场培育在"供给侧"和"需求侧"政策取向上应因地制宜,各有侧重点。
关键词(KeyWords): 新能源汽车;市场培育;供给侧;需求侧;基尼系数法
基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金项目“战略性新兴产业国内市场培育与国际市场地位构建的互动融合机理与对策研究”(编号:71473276)
作者(Author): 熊勇清,陈曼琳
参考文献(References):
- [1]姜江,韩祺.新能源汽车产业的技术创新与市场培育[J].改革,2011,(7):57-63.[Jiang Jiang,Han Qi.Technology Innovation and Market Cultivation of New Energy Vehicles Industry[J].Reform,2011,(7):57-63.]
- [2]熊勇清,刘凡.新兴产业发展阶段,成长导向与稳健性评估:以光伏,风电,光热产业为例[J].中国科技论坛,2015,(8):58-64.[Xiong Yongqing,Liu Fan.Emerging Industry Development Stage,Growth Orientation and Conservative Evaluation:Taking Photovoltaic,Wind Power,Solar Thermal Industries as Examples[J].Forum on Science and Technology in China,2015,(8):58-64.]
- [3]熊勇清,黄健柏.光伏产业困境摆脱与市场的协同培育[J].改革,2013,(12):52-57.[Xiong Yongqing,Huang Jianbai.Casting off the Predicament of Photovoltaic Industry and the Co-cultivation of the Market[J].Reform,2013,(12):52-57.]
- [4]Florenthal B,Grossman P Z.Barriers to Adoption of Hybrid Cars in the Midwest:Focusing on Generation Y[J].Behavioral Sciences,2009,21(1):64-79.
- [5]Gould J,Golob T F.Clean Air Forever?A Longitudinal Analysis of Opinions about Air Pollution and Electric Vehicles[J].Transportation Research Part D:Transport and Environment,1998,3(3):157-169.
- [6]卢超,尤建新,戎珂,等.新能源汽车产业政策的国际比较研究[J].科研管理,2014,(12):26-34.[Lu Chao,You Jianxin,Rong Ke,et al.International Comparison of Industrial Policies for New Energy Vehicles[J].Science Research Management,2014,(12):26-34.]
- [7]余斌,平新乔,张占斌,等.“十三五”期间的中国经济增长改革传媒发行人,编辑总监王佳宁对话九位经济学者[J].改革,2015,(1):5-40.[Yu Bin,Ping Xinqiao,Zhang Zhanbin,et al.China's Economic Growth During the 13th Five-Year Plan Period Reform the Media Publisher Editorial Director Jia-ning Wang Dialogue with 9 Economic Scholars[J].Reform,2015,(1):5-40.]
- [8]Karras G.Government Spending and Private Consumption:SomeInternational Evidence[J].Journal of Money,Credit and Banking,1994,(26):9-22.
- [9]孙虹乔.农村基础设施建设与消费需求的增长:基于1978-2009年经验数据的实证[J].消费经济,2011,(5):33-36.[Sun Hongqiao.The Growth of the Rural Infrastructure Construction and Consumption Demand:Based on Empirical Data from 1978 to2009[J].Consumption Economy,2011,(5):33-36.]
- [10]杨智峰,陈霜华,吴化斌.挤入还是挤出:中国公共投资支出对居民消费的影响[J].中南财经政法大学学报,2013,(6):60-68.[Yang Zhifeng,Chen Shuanghua,Wu Huabin.Crowd in or out:Effect of Public Investment Expenditure on Consumption in China[J].Journal of Zhongnan University of Economics and Law,2013,(6):60-68.]
- [11]张勇,蒲勇健,史乐峰.电动汽车充电基础设施建设与政府策略分析[J].中国软科学,2014,(6):167-181.[Zhang Yong,Pu Yongjian,Shi Lefeng.Analysis on Electric Vehicle Charging Infrastructure and Government Strategy[J].China Soft Science,2014,(6):167-181.]
- [12]李奎,陈丽佳.基于创新双螺旋模型的战略性新兴产业促进政策体系研究[J].中国软科学,2013,(12):179-186.[Li Kui,Chen Lijia.Research on Supporting Policy System for Strategic Emerging Industries Based on Double Helix Innovation Model[J].China Soft Science,2013,(12):179-186.]
- [13]周亚虹,蒲余路,陈诗一,等.政府扶持与新型产业发展:以新能源为例[J].经济研究,2015,50(6):147-161.[Zhou Yahong,Pu Yulu,Chen Shiyi,et al.Government Support and Development of Emerging Industries:A New Energy Industry Survey[J].Economic Research Journal,2015,50(6):147-161.]
- [14]肖兴志.中国战略性新兴产业发展的财税政策建议[J].财政研究,2011,(12):51-54.[Xiao Xingzhi,Finance and Taxation Policy Suggestions on the Development of China's Strategic Emerging Industries[J].Public Finance Research,2011,(12):51-54.]
- [15]Polo A L,Haas R.An International Overview of Promotion Policies for Grid-connected Photovoltaic Systems[J].Progress in Photovoltaics:Research and Applications,2014,22(2):248-273.
- [16]郭晓丹,何文韬,肖兴志.战略性新兴产业的政府补贴,额外行为与研发活动变动[J].宏观经济研究,2011,(11):63-69.[Guo Xiaodan,He Wentao,Xiao Xingzhi.Government Subsidy,Additional Changes and R&D Variation of Strategic Emerging Industries[J].Macroeconomics,2011,(11):63-69.]
- [17]崔海燕,杭斌.收入差距,习惯形成与城镇居民消费行为[J].管理工程学报,2014,(3):135-140.[Cui Haiyan,Hang Bin.Income Difference,Habit Formation and Consumption Behavior of Urban Households in China[J].Journal of Industrial Engineering/Engineering Management,2014,(3):135-140.]
- [18]孙晓华,王林.范式转换,新兴产业演化与市场生态位培育:以新能源汽车为例[J].经济学家,2014,(5):54-62.[Sun Xiaohua,Wang Lin.Emerging Industry Evolution and Market Cultivation of Ecological Niche:A New Energy Industry Survey[J].Economist,2014,(5):54-62.]
- [19]刘颖琦,王静宇.电动汽车示范运营的政策与商业模式创新:全球经验及中国实践[J].中国软科学,2014,(12):1-16.[Liu Yingqi,Wang Jingyu.EV Demonstration Global Policy and Business Model Innovation:Global Experiences and China's Practices[J].China Soft Science,2014,(12):1-16.]
- [20]薛奕曦,邵鲁宁,尤建新,等.面向新能源汽车的社会:技术域分析及其转型推动研究[J].中国软科学,2013,(3):78-88.[Xue Yixi,Shao Luning,You Jianxin,et al.Research on Transition to Alternative Fuel Vehicles:Social:Technical Regime Analysis in China[J].China Soft Science,2013,(3):78-88.]
- [21]柳卸林,高伟,吕萍,等.从光伏产业看中国战略性新兴产业的发展模式[J].科学学与科学技术管理,2012,33(1):116-125.[Liu Xielin,Gao Wei,LV Ping,et al.The Implication of Development of Photovoltaic Industry for Strategic Emerging Industry in China[J].Science of Science and Management of S.&T,2012,33(1):116-125.]
- [22]陆国庆,王舟,张春宇.中国战略性新兴产业政府创新补贴的绩效研究[J].经济研究,2014,49(7):44-55.[Lu Guoqing,Wang Zhou,Zhang Chunyu.Research on the Performance of Subsidizing Innovation for Chinese Strategic Emerging Industry[J].Economic Research Journal,2014,49(7):44-55.]
- [23]黄涛,胡宜国,胡宜朝.地区人均GDP分布的基尼系数分析[J].管理世界,2006,(5):45-51.[Huang Tao,Hu Yiguo,Hu Yichao.An Analysis of Regional Gini Coefficient of Per Capita GDP[J].Management World,2006,(5):45-51.]
- [24]刘华军,何礼伟,杨骞.中国人口老龄化的空间非均衡及分布动态演进:1989-2011[J].人口研究,2014,38(2):71-82.[Liu Huajun,He Liwei,Yang Qian.Spatial Inequality and Distributional Dynamics of Population Ageing in China,1989-2011[J].Population Research,2014,38(2):71-82.]
- [25]孙百才,刘云鹏.中国地区间与性别间的教育公平测度:2002-2012年:基于人口受教育年限的基尼系数分析[J].清华大学教育研究,2014,(3):87-95.[Sun Baicai,Liu Yunpeng.Estimating Educational Equality Between Regions and Genders in China:Based on Gini Coefficients of Education from2002 to 2012[J].Tsinghua Journal of Education,2014,(3):87-95.]
- [26]王连军,张宝东.高校学生消费差异分析:基于基尼系数分解理论的实证研究[J].统计与信息论坛,2007,22(2):107-112.[Wang Lianjun,Zhang Baodong.The Analysis of College Students Consumption Difference:Based on the Theory of Gini Coefficient Decomposition[J].Stistics&Information Forum,2007,22(2):107-112.]
- [27]Camilo Dagum.A New Approach to the Decomposition of the Gini Income Inequality Ratio[J].Empirical Economics,1997,(22):515-531.
- [28]Silber J.Factor Components,Population Subgroups and the Computation of the Gini Index of Inequality[J].The Review of Economics and Statistics,1989,71(1):107-115.
- [29]程永宏.基尼系数组群分解新方法研究:从城乡二亚组到多亚组[J].经济研究,2008,(8):124-135.[Cheng Yonghong.A New Decomposition of Gini-coefficient by Population Subgroups[J].Economic Research Journal,2008,(8):124-135.]