毛显强,曾桉,胡涛,邢有凯,刘胜强

• 1:北京师范大学环境学院
• 2:环境保护部环境与经济政策研究中心

摘要(Abstract)：

随着我国污染减排形势的日益严峻,采用协同控制措施实现多种污染物控制目标逐渐成为一种趋势,而合理评价减排措施的协同效应是正确选择协同控制措施和制定协同控制规划方案的基础。本研究首次从环境-经济-技术角度系统地提出了技术减排措施的协同控制效应评价方法,并以火电行业为案例进行分析。采用协同控制效应坐标系、污染物减排量交叉弹性(Elsa/b)分析和单位污染物减排成本等方法评价技术减排措施对SO2、NOx和CO2的协同控制效应,三种评价方法相互配合,可以帮助我们从多角度检验不同减排措施的协同效果。对火电行业技术减排措施进行协同控制效应坐标系和污染物减排量交叉弹性分析的结果表明,末端治理措施不具有协同性,而前端控制措施和过程控制措施具有较好的协同性。单位污染物减排成本评价的结果表明,末端治理措施优先度排序靠后,而前端控制措施和过程控制措施排序靠前,且针对不同污染物的排序结果有所不同。在进行协同减排方案设计和规划时,应根据决策需要选择适宜的评价方法,参考评价结果选择最为成本有效的措施。

关键词(KeyWords)： 技术减排措施;协同控制效应评价;火电行业

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 美国能源基金会中国可持续能源项目(编号:G-0911-11642);; 环境保护行业性公益项目(编号:201009051)

作者(Author): 毛显强,曾桉,胡涛,邢有凯,刘胜强

参考文献(References)：

• [1]丁一汇,李巧萍,柳艳菊,等.空气污染与气候变化[J].气象,2009,35(3):3-14.[Ding Yihui,Li Qiaoping,Liu Yanju,et al.Atmospheric Aerosols,Air Pollution and Climate Change[J].Meteorological Monthly,2009,35(3):3-14.]
• [2]王金南,宁淼,严刚,等.实施气候友好的大气污染防治战略[J].中国软科学,2010,(10):28-37.[Wang Jinnan,Ning Miao,YanGang,et al.Implementing Climate-friendly Strategy for Air PollutionPrevention and Control[J].China Soft Science Magazine,2010,(10):28-37.]
• [3]Pearce D.The Secondary Benefits of Greenhouse Gas Control[M].CSERGE Working Paper.London:University College,1992:92-12.
• [4]IPCC.IPCC Second Assessment Report:Climate Change1995[M].Switzerland:IPCC,1995:50-51.
• [5]Tollefsen P,Rypdal K,Torvanger A,et al.Air Pollution Policies inEurope:Efficiency Gains From Integrating Climate Effects withDamage Costs to Health and Crops[J].Environmental Science andPolicy,2009,(12):870-881.
• [6]Wang Xiaodong,Smith K.Secondary Benefits of Greenhouse GasControl:Health Impacts in China[J].Environmental Science&Technology,1999,33(18):3056-3061.
• [7]Rypdal K.Nordic Air Quality Co-Benefits from European Post-2012Climate Policies[J].Energy Policy,2007,(35):6309-6322.
• [8]Gielen D,Chen Changhong.The CO2Emission Reduction Benefits ofChinese Energy Policies and Environmental Policies:A Case Studyfor Shanghai,Period 1995-2020[J].Ecological Economics,2001,(39):257-270.
• [9]Chae Y.Co-benefit Analysis of An air Quality Management Plan andGreenhouse Gas Reduction Strategies in the Seoul Metropolitan Area[J].Environmental Science and Policy,2010,(13):205-216.
• [10]李丽平,周国梅.切莫忽视污染减排的协同效应[J].环境保护,2009,(24):36-38.[Li Liping,Zhou Guomei.Do not Ignore theCo-Benefits of Pollution Reduction[J].Environmental Protection,2009,(24):36-38.]
• [11]田春秀,李丽平,胡涛,等.气候变化与环保政策的协同效应[J].环境保护,2009,(12):67-68.[Tian Chunxiu,Li Liping,Hu Tao,et al.Co-benefits of Climate Change and EnvironmentalProtection Policy[J].Environmental Protection,2009,(12):67-68.]
• [12]胡涛,田春秀,李丽平,等.协同效应对中国气候变化的政策影响[J].环境保护,2004,(9):56-58.[Hu Tao,Tian Chunxiu,Li Liping,et al.Influence of Co-benefit on Policy in China[J].Environmental Protection,2004,(9):56-58.]
• [13]李丽平,周国梅,季浩宇,等.污染减排的协同效应评价研究:以攀枝花市为例[J].中国人口.资源与环境,2010,20(5):91-95.[Li Liping,Zhou Guomei,Ji Haoyu,et al.Study of Co-Benefits Assessment of Pollution Reduction:A Case Study inPanzhihua[J].China Population,Resources and Environment,2010,20(5):91-95.]
• [14]国家发展和改革委员会.国家重点节能技术推广目录(第一批)[M].北京:国家发展和改革委员会,2008:4-11.[NationalDevelopment and Reform Commission.National Extension Directoryof Important Energy Conservation Technology(1st Batch)[M].Beijing:National Development and Reform Commission,2008:4-11.]
• [15]国家发展和改革委员会.国家重点节能技术推广目录(第二批)[M].北京:国家发展和改革委员会,2009:7-14.[NationalDevelopment and Reform Commission.National Extension Directoryof Important Energy Conservation Technology(2nd Batch)[M].Beijing:National Development and Reform Commission,2009:7-14.]
• [16]王志轩,朱法华,等.火电二氧化硫环境影响与控制对策[M].北京:中国环境科学出版社,2002.[Wang Zhixuan,Zhu Fahua,etal.Impact and Control of SO2 in Thermal Power Industry[M].Beijing:China Environmental Science Press,2002.]
• [17]环境保护部.火电厂氮氧化物防治技术政策[M].北京:环境保护部,2010:27-29.[Ministry of Environmental Protection.NOxPrevention and Control Technology and Policy for Thermal PowerIndustry[M].Beijing:Ministry of Environmental Protection,2010:27-29.]
• [18]杜秋平.利用烟气脱硫技术控制大气污染[J].华北电力技术,1999,(11):29-32.[Du Qiuping.Using Flue Gas DesulfurizingTechnology for Controlling Atmospheric Pollution[J].North ChinaElectric Power,1999,(11):29-32.]
• [19]苏永.火力发电厂烟气脱硝技术研究[J].热电技术,2009,(2):40-44.[Su Yong.Study of Flue Gas Denitration Technology forThermal Power Industry[J].Cogeneration Power Technology,2009,(2):40-44.]
• [20]气候组织.CCS在中国:现状、挑战和机遇[M].北京:气候组织,2010.[The Climate Group.Towards Market Transformation:CCS in China[M].Beijing:The Climate Group,2010.]
• [21]Michale Hubler,Andreas Keller.Energy Saving Via FDI?.Empirical Evidence from Developing Countries[J].Environmentand Development Economics,2009,15:59-80.
• [22]李小平,卢现祥.国际贸易、污染产业转移和中国工业CO2排放[J].经济研究,2010,45(1):15-26.[Li Xiaoping,LuXianxiang.International Trade,Pollution Industry Transfer andChinese Industries’CO2 Emissions[J].Economical ResearchJournal,2010,45(1):15-26.]
• [23]Perkins,Neumayer.Transnational Linkages and the Spillover ofEnvironment-efficiency into Developing Countries[J].GlobalEnvironmental Change,2009,(19):375-383.
• [24]陈诗一.能源消耗、二氧化碳排放与中国工业的可持续发展[J].经济研究,2009,44(4):41-55.[Chen Shiyi.EnergyConsumption,CO2 Emission and Sustainable Development inChinese Industry[J].Economical Research Journal,2009,44(4):41-55.]