钟方雷,郭爱君,张彦琼

• 1:兰州大学经济学院
• 2:中国科学院寒区旱区环境与工程研究所内陆河流域生态水文重点实验室
• 3:兰州财经大学外语学院

摘要(Abstract)：

与传统学科界限鲜明不同,生态经济学强调跨学科交叉研究,注重让问题来决定研究工具集,而不是由研究工具来决定合适的对象。由于生态经济问题涉及生态系统与社会经济系统,研究对象属性多样、关系复杂,既有采用传统意义上的生态经济学方法如生态系统服务价值核算等方法,也包括生活质量、生计途径、消费评估等社会学方法。因此,采取关注学科主要方法发展演化的思路,难以系统地总结生态经济研究进展。我国西北地区生态环境脆弱,经济发展相对落后,无疑是生态经济研究的"天然典型实验场",取得了大量的研究成果。遵循从研究对象出发的思路,采用经典的ImPACTS等式框架,以更宽泛的视野和系统的思维框架综述了西北地区典型生态经济实证研究的思路,即:采用等级层次分析方法研究生态系统和经济系统某个或多个结构性成分及其关系,再用实际结果检验其正确性。综述重要进展包括:可持续性衡量从物质、能量和信息角度开展了水资源承载力、生态足迹、能值与上升性的研究;生态系统服务和自然资本的价值评估开展了条件估值和选择模型,以及环境经济账户、物质流等集成核算工作;人类福利状况评价开展了幸福及生活质量核算工作;开展了生态补偿全流程的实证研究工作;集成模拟模型开展了空间建模环境的构建及简单自然过程的模拟,以LUCC和生态补偿为例进行了较好的自然过程和人文因素相耦合的集成模拟研究;以社会适应性能力作为整体性指标研究了社会资源对水资源的适应作用,将社会资源解耦为文化类型、社会资本和制度三个维度进行实证分析。在此基础上,提出了未来开展研究的建议。

关键词(KeyWords)： ImPACTS等式;典型生态经济问题;研究综述;西北地区

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金面上项目“需水管理导向的农村居民用水行为研究——以黑河流域为例”(批准号:41571516);; 中国博士后科学基金项目“基于LCA和DEA方法结合的西北绿洲农业生态经济效率研究”(批准号:2016M590980)

作者(Author): 钟方雷,郭爱君,张彦琼

参考文献(References)：

• [1]COSTANZA R.What is ecological economics?[J].Ecological economics,1998(1):1-7.
• [2]科斯坦萨,乔根森.理解和解决21世纪环境问题——面向一个新的、集成的硬问题科学[M].徐中民,张志强,张齐兵,等,译.郑州:黄河水利出版社,2004.[COSTANZA R,JORGENSEN S E.Understanding and solving environmental problems in the 21st century:toward a new integrated hard problem science[M].Translated by XU Zhongmin,ZHANG Zhiqiang,ZHANG Qibing,et al.Zhengzhou:The Yellow River water Conservancy Press,2002.]
• [3]郝尔曼·E·戴利,乔舒亚·法利.生态经济学——原理与应用[M].徐中民,张志强,钟方雷,等,译.郑州:黄河水利出版社,2007.[DALY H E,FARLEY J.Ecoligical economics:principles and applications[M].Translated by XU Zhongmin,ZHANG Zhiqiang,ZHONG Fanglei,et al.Zhengzhou:The Yellow River water Conservancy Press,2003.]
• [4]徐中民,张志强,程国栋.当代生态经济的综合研究综述[J].地球科学进展,2000,15(6):688-694.[XU Zhongmin,ZHANG Zhiqiang,CHENG Guodong.Review of ecological economics[J].Advance in earth science,2000,15(6):688-694.]
• [5]周维佳,廖望科,陈春艳.基于国际视野的中国生态经济研究方法进展综述[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2015,25(S1):300-304.[ZHOU Weijia,LIAO Wangke,CHEN Chunyan.Review of China's eco-economic methods based on international outlook[J].China population,resources and environment,2015,25(S1):300-304.]
• [6]钟方雷,徐中民,张志强.生态经济学与传统经济学差异辨析[J].地球科学进展,2008,23(4):401-407.[ZHONG Fanglei,XU Zhongmin,ZHANG Zhiqiang.Identifying key differences between ecological economics and conventional economics[J].Advances in earth science,2008,23(4):401-407.]
• [7]徐中民,程国栋.人地系统中人文因素作用的分析框架探讨[J].科技导报,2008,26(3):86-92.[XU Zhongmin,CHENG Guodong.Framework to address human factors in a human-earth system[J].Science&technology review,2008,26(3):86-92.]
• [8]DAILY G C,EHRLICH P.Population,sustainability and earth's carrying capacity[J].Bioscience,1992,42:761-771.
• [9]WAGGONER P R,AUSUBEL J H.A framework for sustainability science:a renovated IPAT identity[J].Proc.Natl.Acad.Sci.USA,2002,99:7860-7865.
• [10]徐中民,程国栋,邱国玉.可持续性评价的ImPACTS等式[J].地理学报,2005,60(2):198-208.[XU Zhongmin,CHENG Guodong,QIU Guoyu.ImPACTS identity of sustainability assessment[J].Acta geographica sinica,2005,60(2):198-208.]
• [11]程国栋.虚拟水——中国水资源安全战略的新思路[J].中国科学院院刊,2003(4):260-265.[CHENG Guodong.Virtual water:a strategic instrument to achieve water security[J].Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences,2003(4):260-265.]
• [12]徐中民,龙爱华,张志强.虚拟水的理论方法及在甘肃省的应用[J].地理学报,2003,58(6):861-869.[XU Zhongmin,LONG Aihua,ZHANG Zhiqiang.Virtual water consumption calculation and analysis of Gansu Province in 2000[J].Acta geographica sinica,2003,58(6):861-869.]
• [13]焦文献,徐中民,尚海洋,等.基于Im PACT等式的人类活动环境影响分析——以甘肃省虚拟水消费为例[J].冰川冻土,2006,28(5):748-754.[JIAO Wenxian,XU Zhongmin,SHANG Haiyang,et al.Analysis of environment impact of human activities based on Im PACT identity:a case study of virtual water consumption in Gansu Province[J].Journal of glaciology and geocryology,2006,28(5):748-754.]
• [14]徐中民,宋晓谕,程国栋.虚拟水战略新论[J].冰川冻土,2013(2):490-495.[XU Zhongmin,SONG Xiaoyu,CHENG Guodong.A new explanation of virtual water strategy[J].Journal of glaciology and geocryology,2013(2):490-495.]
• [15]徐中民,张志强,程国栋.甘肃省1998年生态足迹计算与分析[J].地理学报,2000,55(5):607-616.[XU Zhongmin,ZHANG Zhiqiang,CHENG Guodong.The calculation and analysis of ecological footprints of Gansu Province[J].Acta geographica sinica,2000,55(5):607-616.]
• [16]武翠芳,徐中民.黑河流域生态足迹空间差异分析[J].干旱区地理,2008,31(6):799-806.[WU Cuifang,XU Zhongmin.Spatial difference of ecological footprint in Heihe River Basin[J].Arid land geography.2008,31(6):799-806.]
• [17]HOEKSTRA A Y.Human appropriation of natural capital:a comparison of ecological footprint and water footprint analysis[J].Ecological economics,2009,68(7):1963-1974.
• [18]龙爱华,徐中民,张志强,等.甘肃省2000年水资源足迹的初步估算[J].资源科学,2005,16(3):123-129.[LONG Aihua,XU Zhongmin,ZHANG Zhiqiang,et al.Primary estimation of water footprint of Gansu Province in 2000[J].Resources science,2005,16(3):123-129.]
• [19]龙爱华,张志强,徐中民,等.甘肃省水资源足迹与消费模式分析[J].水科学进展,2005(3):418-425.[LONG Aihua,ZHANG Zhiqiang,XU Zhongmin,et al.Analysis of water footprint and consumption pattern in Gansu Province[J].Advances in water science,2005(3):418-425.]
• [20]ODUM H T.Environmental accounting:energy and environmental decision making[M].New York:John Wiley&Sons Inc,1996:15-34.
• [21]杜鹏,徐中民.甘肃生态经济系统的能值分析及其可持续性评估[J].地球科学进展,2006,21(9):982-988.[DU Peng,XU Zhongmin.Emergy analysis and sustainability assessment of ecological economics system in Gansu Province[J].Advances in earth science,2006,21(9):982-988.]
• [22]黄茄莉,徐中民.上升性理论在经济系统中的应用——以甘肃省为例[J].生态学报,2007,27(11):4785-4792.[HUANG Jiali,XU Zhongmin.The ascendency formula and its application in economic systems:take Gansu Province as a case study[J].Acta ecologica sinica,2007,27(11):4785-4792.]
• [23]XU Zhongmin,CHENG Guodong,CHEN Dongjin,et al.Development capacity and sustainable development of China[J].Ecological economics,2002,40(3):369-378.
• [24]黄茄莉,徐中民,王康.甘州区社会经济系统水循环研究[J].水利学报,2010,41(9):1114-1120.[HUANG Jiali,XU Zhongmin,WANG Kang.Study on socio-economic water cycle in Ganzhou[J].Journal of hydraulic engineering,2010,41(9):1114-1120.]
• [25]徐中民,张志强,程国栋,等.额济纳旗生态系统恢复的总经济价值评估[J].地理学报,2002,57(1):107-116.[XU Zhongmin,ZHANG Zhiqiang,CHENG Guodong,et al.Measuring the total economic value of restoring Ejina Banner's ecosystem services[J].Acta geographica sinica,2002,57(1):107-116.]
• [26]徐中民,张志强,龙爱华,等.环境选择模型在生态系统管理中的应用——以黑河流域额济纳旗为例[J].地理学报,2003,58(3):398-405.[XU Zhongmin,ZHANG Zhiqiang,LONG Aihua,et al.Choice modeling and its potential application to ecosystem management and preservation:taking Ejina Banner as an example[J].Acta geographica sinica,2003,58(3):398-405.]
• [27]唐增,徐中民.CVM评价农户对农业水价的承受力——以甘肃省张掖市为例[J].冰川冻土,2009,31(3):560-564.[TANG Zeng,XU Zhongmin.The farmers bearing capacity of irrigation water price assessed by CVM:taking Zhangye Municipality as a case[J].Journal of glaciology and geocryology,2009,31(3):560-564.]
• [28]United Nations Statistics Division,United Nations Environment Programme.Integrated environmental and economic accounting:an operational manual[M].New York:United nations,2000.
• [29]徐中民,陈东景.基于社会核算体系的平川乡经济影响乘子分析[J].冰川冻土,2002,24(4):368-373.[XU Zhongmin,CHEN Dongjing.Economy impact analysis of Pingchuan county based on social accounting matrix[J].Journal of glaciology and geocryology,2002,24(4):368-373.]
• [30]陈东景,程国栋,李守中,等.张掖市环境经济综合核算[J].兰州大学学报,2004,40(3):76-83.[CHEN Dongjing,CHENG Guodong,LI Shouzhong,et al.An integrated environmental and economic accounting of Zhangye City[J].Journal of Lanzhou University(natural sciences),2004,40(3):76-83.]
• [31]程国栋,徐中民,徐进祥.建立中国国民幸福生活核算体系的构想[J].地理学报,2005,60(6):883-893.[CHENG Guodong,XU Zhongmin,XU Jinxiang.Vision of integrated happiness accounting system in China[J].Acta geographica sinica,2005,60(6):883-893.]
• [32]彭浩,曾刚,徐中民.黑河流域居民生活质量研究[J].人文地理,2009(4):66-71.[PENG Hao,ZENG Gang,XU Zhongmin.Study on the quality of life of the residents in Heihe River Basin[J].Human geography,2009(4):66-71.]
• [33]程怀文,徐中民,李玉文.基于幸福生活预期评价黑河流域各地社会发展[J].冰川冻土,2011,33(3):676-682.[CHENG Huaiwen,XU Zhongmin,LI Yuwen.Applying happy lifeexpectance to appraise the development status of different areas within the Heihe River Basin[J].Journal of glaciology and geocryology,2011,33(3):676-682.]
• [34]宋晓谕,刘玉卿,邓晓红,等.基于分布式水文模型和福利成本法的生态补偿空间选择研究[J].生态学报,2012,32(24):7722-7729.[SONG Xiaoyu,LIU Yuqing,DENG Xiaohong,et al.Spatial targeting of payments for ecosystem services based on SWAT model and cost-benefit analysis[J].Acta ecologica sinica,2012,32(24):7722-7729.]
• [35]刘玉卿,徐中民,南卓铜.基于SWAT模型和最小数据法的黑河流域上游生态补偿研究[J].农业工程学报,2012,28(10):124-130.[LIU Yuqing,XU Zhongmin,NAN Zhuotong.Study on ecological compensation in upper stream of Heihe River Basin based on SWAT model and minimum-data approach[J].Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering,2012,28(10):124-130.]
• [36]唐增,黄茄莉,徐中民.生态系统服务供给量的确定——最小数据法在黑河流域中游的应用[J].生态学报,2010,30(9):2354-2360.[TANG Zeng,HUANG Jiali,XU Zhongmin.Modeling the supply of water services:the application of minimum data approach in Ganzhou District,Heihe River[J].Acta ecologica sinica,2010,30(9):2354-2360.]
• [37]戴其文,赵雪雁.生态补偿机制中若干关键科学问题——以甘南藏族自治州草地生态系统为例[J].地理学报,2010,65(4):494-506.[DAI Qiwen,ZHAO Xueyan.Discussion on several key scientific issues of eco-compensation mechanism in Gannan Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture[J].Acta geographica sinica,2010,65(4):494-506.]
• [38]刘玉卿,宋晓谕,钟方雷,等.最小数据方法在舟曲县生态补偿中的应用[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2011,21(6):142-147.[LIU Yuqing,SONG Xiaoyu,ZHONG Fanglei,et al.Application of the minimum-data approach in Zhouqu County ecological compensation[J].China population,resources and environment,2011,21(6):142-147.]
• [39]唐增,徐中民,武翠芳,等.生态补偿标准的确定——最小数据法及其在民勤的应用[J].冰川冻土,2010,32(5):1044-1048.[TANG Zeng,XU Zhongmin,WU Cuifang,et al.Determination of the eco-compensation criteria:an application of the Minimal Data Method in Minqin,Gansu[J].Journal of glaciology and geocryology,2010,32(5):1044-1048.]
• [40]赵雪雁,董霞,范君君,等.甘南黄河水源补给区生态补偿方式的选择[J].冰川冻土,2010,32(1):204-210.[ZHAO Xueyan,DONG Xia,FAN Junjun,et al.The selection of ecological compensation mode in the Yellow River water supply areas of Gannan,Gansu[J].Journal of glaciology and geocryology,2010,32(1):204-210.]
• [41]赵雪雁,李巍,王学良.生态补偿研究中的几个关键问题[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2012,22(2):1-7.[ZHAO Xueyan,LI Wei,WANG Xueliang.Several key issues of ecological compensation research[J].China population,resources and environment,2012,22(2):1-7.]
• [42]王立安,钟方雷,苏芳.西部生态补偿与缓解贫困关系的研究框架[J].经济地理,2009,(9):1552-1557.[WANG Li'an,ZHONG Fanglei,SU Fang.The framework of research on the relationship between PES sheme and poverty alleviation in the western China[J].Economic geography,2009,29(9):1552-1557.]
• [43]焦文献,徐中民.人文因素作用集成模拟模型国际研究进展[J].冰川冻土,2010,32(2):438-443.[JIAO Wenxian,XU Zhongmin.An overview of the most integrated simulation models[J].Journal of glaciology and geocryology,2010,32(2):438-443.]
• [44]梁友嘉,徐中民,钟方雷.基于SD和CLUE-S模型的张掖市甘州区土地利用情景分析[J].地理研究,2011,30(3):564-576.[LIANG Youjia,XU Zhongmin,ZHONG Fanglei.Land use scenario analyses by based on system dynamic model and CLUE-S model at regional scale:a case study of Ganzhou District of Zhangye City[J].Geographical research,2011,30(3):564-576.]
• [45]徐中民,龙爱华.中国社会化水资源稀缺评价[J].地理学报,2004,59(6):982-988.[XU Zhongmin,LONG Aihua.The primary study on assessing social water scarcity in China[J].Acta geographica sinica,2004,59(6):982-988.]
• [46]钟方雷,尹小娟,徐中民.黑河中游甘州区居民文化类型及其对自然环境的认知[J].冰川冻土,2012,34(4):972-982.[ZHONG Fanglei,YIN Xiaojuan,XU Zhongmin.Resident culture values and natural environment perception in Ganzhou District in the middle reaches of Heihe River[J].Journal of glaciology and geocryology,2012,34(4):972-982.]
• [47]张小君,钟方雷,徐中民,等.运用文化理论和模糊网络分析评价黑河中游最优水资源管理风格[J].冰川冻土,2013,35(1):224-232.[ZHANG Xiaojun,ZHONG Fanglei,XU Zhongmin,et al.Applying cultural theory and fuzzy network analysis to evaluate the optimal water resources management style in the middle reaches of the Heihe River[J].Journal of glaciology and geocryology,2013,35(1):224-232.]
• [48]李玉文,徐中民.社会资本定量评价方法及应用——以黑河流域为例[J].冰川冻土,2007,29(5):830-836.[LI Yuwen,XU Zhongmin.Quantificational appraise of social capital:method and application:a case study in Heihe Drainage Basin[J].Journal of glaciology and geocryology.2007,29(5):830-836.]
• [49]赵雪雁.社会资本与经济增长及环境影响的关系研究[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2010,(2):68-73.[ZHAO Xueyan.The relationship between social capital and economic growth,environment impact[J].China population,resources and environment,2010,(2):68-73.]
• [50]刘建国,陈文江,徐中民.干旱区流域水制度绩效及影响因素分析[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2012,22(10):13-18.[LIU Jianguo,CHEN Wenjiang,XU Zhongmin.Analysis on water institution performance and its impact factors in basin context in arid regions[J].China population,resources and environment,2012,22(10):13-18.]
• [51]程国栋,徐中民,钟方雷.张掖市面向幸福的水资源管理战略规划[J].冰川冻土,2011,33(6):1193-1202.[CHENG Guodong,XU Zhongmin,ZHONG Fanglei.Happiness oriented water resources management strategic planning in Zhangye Municipality[J].Journal of glaciology and geocryology,2011,33(6):1193-1202.]